radiomuseum.org

 

EL33 (EL33)/ 6M6

Moderatoren:
Jacob Roschy Martin Renz Ernst Erb Bernhard Nagel Eilert Menke 
 
Bitte klicken Sie ganz oben rechts das blaue Info-Zeichen, um Instruktionen/Hilfe zu erhalten.
Forum » Röhren und Halbleiter » RADIOROEHREN / HALBLEITER IM MUSEUM » EL33 (EL33)/ 6M6
           
Júlio Branco
Júlio Branco
 
P  Beiträge: 188
Schema: 124
Bilder: 649
18.Apr.07 01:22

Anzahl Danke: 79
Antworten  |  Sie sind nicht eingeloggt (Gast).   1

Dear Members

 

This information can be very useful goes my dear friends of the radio.

The tube EL33 directly can be substituted by the tube 6M6.

Best regards

Júlio Branco

Dieser Beitrag wurde am 24.Apr.07 20:14 von Júlio Branco editiert.

Roy Johnson
 
 
GB  Beiträge: 280
Schema: 21
Bilder: 131
18.Apr.07 16:14

Anzahl Danke: 70
Antworten  |  Sie sind nicht eingeloggt (Gast).   2

Dear Julio,

I have just seen that you also posted to the EL33, so I copy my comments made to the 6V6 below  as a caution.

"The 6V6 and EL33 are NOT equivalent!  A hasty note of warning!

They have the same base, connections and heater volts but differ considerably.  THe heater current of the EL33 is 0.9A compared with 0.45A for the 6V6.

More seriously the biasing requirements are different and could cause dangerous excess anode currents.  Replacing an EL33 with a 6V6 without changing grid bias would not be a good idea!

The power limitation on the EL33 is 9W whereas the 6V6 is 12W; the output impedance is different.

Whilst it may "work" to exchange these tubes it should not be done without circuit changes.

Regards to all,   Roy"

############################################################

Also kindly act please on Mr Erb's request to remove "directly" in your posting so that there is no possible confusion!  We must be careful not to leave information that could prove dangerous to equipment or to people!  Thank you.

Kind regards,   Roy


Jacob Roschy
Jacob Roschy
Moderator
D  Beiträge: 1620
Schema: 17
Bilder: 69
18.Apr.07 19:52

Anzahl Danke: 21
Antworten  |  Sie sind nicht eingeloggt (Gast).   3
As Roy has already mentioned, the 6V6 and EL33 are NOT equivalent ! 
 
Since all data shown in the diagram are those for the EL33 or 6M6, which are fully equivalent to each other, it's most possible, the titel of this data sheet was written wrong. Instead of EL33 / 6V6 it should read EL33 / 6M!
 
  
 
 
6V6 and EL33 / 6M6 are very different in characteristics and performance. They should never be used as replacement to each other !
 
This is clearly obvious by comparing their operating data:
 
 
 
EL33 / 6M6
6V6
 
Anode current
Ia
36
45
mA
Anode dissipation
Pa
9
12
Watts
bias Voltage
Vg1
 - 6
- 12.5
Volts
Cathode resistor
Rk
150
250
Ohms
Mutual conductance
gm
9.5
4.1
mA/V
Load resistance
Ro
7
5
k Ohms
 
 
Avoid to replace a 6V6 by a EL33 / 6M6 ! – This leads to low performance, use it only as temporarily makeshift !
 
NEVER replace an EL33 or 6M6 by a 6V6 ! – This will cause severe overload to the tube and to the circuit as well !
 
Applying the proper bias for the EL33 of –6 V only to the 6V6 will raise its anode current up to 80 mA, which will cause 20 W Anode dissipation !
 
Best Regards,
Jacob
 

Dieser Beitrag wurde am 30.Apr.07 11:07 von Jacob Roschy editiert.

Júlio Branco
Júlio Branco
 
P  Beiträge: 188
Schema: 124
Bilder: 649
24.Apr.07 20:18

Anzahl Danke: 25
Antworten  |  Sie sind nicht eingeloggt (Gast).   4

Dear Members,

 

I ask all excuse goes my previous information. I was induced in mistake by the fact of my manual of tubes to incorrect be. I won't usually check the technical dates of to manual when this it informs us that equivalence direct exists, in fact, to present it date, I have been following the instructions of the manuals and I have always been having success in my work. Then the reason goes the which I don't have the habit of checking the manuals I or in correct the. Inclusively to removes you doubt if he had or in the tube averaged EL33 changed goes the 6V6, the in the manual he felt this information, I made the experience given that had available the tube 6V6, the radio worked, what concluded that EL33 was damaged. I removed to 6V6, I acquired an EL33, being like this with the concluded work and without noticing the mistake that was to commit. I already analysed the tube 6V6 and it is 100 percent, it was not damaged.

 

A thank you very much goes all of the information that gave me on the tubes EL33, 6M6 and 6V6, once again it is confirmed that this forum is very important, and where us been always to learn.

 

Best Regards

Júlio Branco

 

Dieser Beitrag wurde am 26.Apr.07 00:01 von Júlio Branco editiert.

Ernst Erb
Ernst Erb
Ratsmitglied
CH  Beiträge: 5602
Schema: 13736
Bilder: 30895
30.Apr.07 08:49

Anzahl Danke: 20
Antworten  |  Sie sind nicht eingeloggt (Gast).   5

Dear Julio
Nevermind. But it is essential that we also keep record of the faults in publications since we want to achieve a "reference work" here. We are far from that but on a way to it.

I kindly ask you to take this sheet you have shown to us, cross the V so taht it is still well visible and write over it M. Then scan it again and load it up with a text explaining in which book you found it and on which page.

Please do this in your first post by editing - on both entries (tubes). Then everybody has learnt something and a newcomer will not do the same but recognise that that book is wrong. You will rarely ind a book where everything is correct. It is the big gain for us that we can always improve our data to the best - but we will have to take notice of reasons and references, proofs etc.

Ernst Erb
Ernst Erb
Ratsmitglied
CH  Beiträge: 5602
Schema: 13736
Bilder: 30895
15.May.07 08:37

Anzahl Danke: 32
Antworten  |  Sie sind nicht eingeloggt (Gast).   6 Dear Júlio
Please read my post carefully:
We should show by your picture that the sheet you have shown is wrong.
Only by that somebody can immediately see the wrong part in that book.
Lars-G. Lundelin
 
 
FIN  Beiträge: 135
Schema: 23
Bilder: 102
15.May.07 10:56

Anzahl Danke: 23
Antworten  |  Sie sind nicht eingeloggt (Gast).   7 Dear tube friends! At least the following tube-book has wrong information about the relation between EL33 and 6V6. This book is from 1956. With kind regards Lars-G

Anlagen:

Júlio Branco
Júlio Branco
 
P  Beiträge: 188
Schema: 124
Bilder: 649
15.May.07 12:56

Anzahl Danke: 20
Antworten  |  Sie sind nicht eingeloggt (Gast).   8

I'm sorry, Hernst

 

Lately I have been walking with a lot of work, reason for the which I didn't put in the post that suggested to do.

 

Here it is going the alert and so that all of the members of Rmorg, and not only, for everyone that visits this grandiose site to be possessors of this book they make the respective correction.

 

forumdata/users/3656/Tube_EL33_6V6.png

forumdata/users/3656/Radio_tubes_book_page1.png

Best Regards

Júlio Branco

Dieser Beitrag wurde am 15.May.07 13:05 von Júlio Branco editiert.

  
rmXorg